Arlington Mutual Insurance Company

From our humble beginnings nearly 150 years ago, our passion has always been to provide quality insurance with affordable premiums to both our own as well as surrounding Wisconsin communities. Having such a long established history proves that we have survived every challenge of adversity and still stand as strong as ever. Every day, we gladly do all the hard work necessary to protect our insurance customers which aids our communities, our livelihoods and our families.

To find the best insurance in Wisconsin, there is no need to look further. We understand every aspect of insurance and are able to quickly evaluate the needs of anyone seeking assistance. We also understand the lives and concerns of our customers because we are also part of the community and are insurance customers too. We firmly believe that everyone has the equal right to outstanding service, affordable premiums and quality insurance that will be there for you when you need it most.

What are you waiting for? Give our friendly staff a call to get started on securing the things in life you value most.

Arlington Mutual Insurance is a company you can trust, and a company that will be there for you for life.

Homeowners Insurance

Covering your home, personal property and liability.

Learn More

Farmowners Insurance

Coverage for your farm, farmette or hobby farm, including dwellings & outbuildings.

Learn More

Renters Insurance

Coverage for all your personal property & belongings if you currently rent.

Learn More

Insurance Products

Homeowner Policies Covering your home, personal property and liability.
Farmowners Policies Covering your farm house, buildings, personal property, equipment & machinery, livestock and liability.
Renters And Tenants Policies Covering your rented residence & personal property.
Rental And Investment Policies Cost coverage for your rental property or investment property.
Condominium Policies Coverage for your individual condo unit, detached structures, personal property and additional living costs.
Mobile Home policies Covering your residence, rented or seasonal mobile home.
Auto Insurance Quotes available from any Arlington Mutual Insurance Agent.
Contact us today for any of your insurance needs!

WHAT THEY SAYTESTIMONIALSOUR GREAT CLIENTS

"I highly recommend Arlington Mutual Insurance for their Outstanding Customer Service and Amazing Rates! I have been insured with this company for several years now and have had nothing but great experiences with them. My agent is always making sure my policy is updated with the best rates available. I love the fact that I can call or email my agent directly to make changes to my policy and receive a reply in a timely manner."

TS, Poynette

"Best kept secret! Didn’t even know Arlington Mutual has been around for almost 150 years. So glad I found this local insurance company and the wonderful products and excellent service that go along with it."

TT, Pardeeville

"I’ve been an Arlington Mutual policyholder for over 30 years. I appreciate the ease of working with this local company. They are top-notch and on the rare occasion I’ve needed to make a claim, they have been prompt in paying. I feel that Arlington Mutual provides complete coverage at a very fair price. I would recommend them to anyone."

JVD, Mazomanie

"We have been Arlington Mutual policyholders for almost 40 years. I think having a policy with a “Mutual” insurance company is a thing that the big companies cannot compete with in products or services and especially costs. I also like the idea of keeping our money local."

RPL, DeForest

"My immediate family has used Arlington Mutual Insurance for 4 generations. Great Service, Great Products, Great Support, Great Company! How could 4 generations be wrong?"

HBS, Arlington

"Arlington Mutual is an amazing company! They are always ready to assist me with any insurance needs, as well as taking the time to thoroughly explain my coverage and any questions I may have about insurance in general. I cannot recommend Arlington highly enough!"

SJK, Waunakee